The Bible: Alternate Takes

Discussion in 'Religions & Cults' started by MrRING, Jun 13, 2018 at 5:05 PM.

  1. MrRING

    MrRING Justified & Ancient

    Messages:
    4,863
    Likes Received:
    874
    Trophy Points:
    144
    I was reading an article in Archeology magazine about this papyrus and was intrigued about this quote:
    Thinking as a film fans, this got me to thinking about various alternate takes in famous films, from Han Shot First from the remixed Star Wars, to if Dekkard is a replicant or not in the various Blade Runners, and the like. And it made me wonder, has anybody done a "Director's Cut" of the Bible trying to put in alternate takes of famous passages or storylines? I know that the Apocrypha exists, and various other things, but I'm thinking of just variations of the stories presented in the books commonly known as the King James Bible. It would be interesting if putting the different story elements in would change the flow of the overall narrative or the message for believers.
     
    Naughty_Felid and escargot like this.
  2. Jim

    Jim Abominable Snowman

    Messages:
    509
    Likes Received:
    408
    Trophy Points:
    64
    LOCATION:
    NYS
    The Bible is what the Bible is. Believe it or reject it.
     
  3. escargot

    escargot Beloved of Ra

    Messages:
    21,054
    Likes Received:
    10,482
    Trophy Points:
    284
    LOCATION:
    Farkham Hall
    That's not the whole story though. There are 'other' texts, especially about Jesus, which existed at the same time as the ones that made it into the Bible. Who chose them, and why? What features made them more likely to be accepedt or rejected?
     
  4. GingerTabby

    GingerTabby Carbon-based life form

    Messages:
    719
    Likes Received:
    1,079
    Trophy Points:
    139
    LOCATION:
    all lost in the supermarket
    Some insight may be gleaned from the following texts:

    For an examination of how the King James Bible came to be, I would recommend Adam Nicholson's God Secretaries: The Making of the King James Bible (New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 2001).

    For a concise account of the broader history of the Christian Bible, you may wish to consider John Riches's The Bible: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000). Off topic: The Very Short Introduction series covers a wide range of topics and can be quite helpful, imo.
     
  5. maximus otter

    maximus otter Recovering policeman

    Messages:
    1,895
    Likes Received:
    2,649
    Trophy Points:
    184
    LOCATION:
    You don't have the "Need to Know"
    The generally-accepted Bible was formed over a couple of centuries, mainly by acclamation. The process was finished by the 5th century AD.

    If insomnia troubles you, try reading about the process on Wikipedia.

    maximus otter
     
    Timble2 likes this.
  6. escargot

    escargot Beloved of Ra

    Messages:
    21,054
    Likes Received:
    10,482
    Trophy Points:
    284
    LOCATION:
    Farkham Hall
    We have a thread somewhere on the subject of the 'other' accounts of the early life of Jesus, which doesn't come up much in the Bible. Like the occasion when he made someone drop dead with a nasty look or summat.
     
    Naughty_Felid likes this.
  7. Jim

    Jim Abominable Snowman

    Messages:
    509
    Likes Received:
    408
    Trophy Points:
    64
    LOCATION:
    NYS
    Hi, prefer not to get into apologetics on the forum. Simply stated the Bible was compiled using the Hebrew Old Testament (compiled by 600 B.C.) and the books of the New Testament consolidated by the early church in the 5th century AD. These writing were verified in part by the Dead Sea Scrolls (compiled much earlier). There’s some contention on why – which books were chosen to be in the Bible. The Christian belief is that this process was directed spiritually to prevent non-inspired writings from getting into the Bible. Which brings us back to the fact that if one accepts the Bible, attempts to add – alter it are non-spiritual? This is based on ones faith, not science.
     
  8. Mythopoeika

    Mythopoeika I am a meat popsicle

    Messages:
    29,168
    Likes Received:
    13,051
    Trophy Points:
    284
    LOCATION:
    Inside a starship, watching puny humans from afar
    The Bible is an anthology. They didn't do full length novels back then.
     
    escargot and EnolaGaia like this.
  9. Timble2

    Timble2 Imaginary Person

    Messages:
    5,545
    Likes Received:
    461
    Trophy Points:
    164
    LOCATION:
    In a Liminal Zone
    The Book Of Enoch, which didn't make the final cut of western Bibles (only the Ethiopian Church regards it as canon) is interesting stuff, The story of the fall of the angels is a lot more detailed, and some of of their misdeeds are things like teaching humans about fire, and metals (and mating with them). Another section is a bronze age astronomical text. There's quite a few reasons the Ancient Astronauts crowd like this book.
     
    escargot and EnolaGaia like this.
  10. Jim

    Jim Abominable Snowman

    Messages:
    509
    Likes Received:
    408
    Trophy Points:
    64
    LOCATION:
    NYS
    One can believe the Bible’s an anthology. One can add or subtract books from it. The point I’m making is the Bible that’s accepted by many mainstream Christians is none of these. I’m not telling you what to believe. Choose to be a Christian, Atheist, Jewish or just make it up as you go. The forum (as of late) has had in incursion of religious – political BS for me. I’m done.
     
  11. EnolaGaia

    EnolaGaia I knew the job was dangerous when I took it ...

    Messages:
    5,859
    Likes Received:
    5,397
    Trophy Points:
    294
    LOCATION:
    USA
    I'm getting the impression there's a conflict / impasse here, but I'm not sure about its focus or basis.

    I originally read MrRING's opening post to pose the issue of how the biblical narratives might shift (if only piecemeal) if all the variations among those texts accepted by one or more religious institutions / churches were somehow merged or blended.

    I didn't read MrRING's opening post as suggesting such speculative analysis / synthesis could or would involve any text(s) outside the range of those which had been accepted into at least one version of a particular sect's / church's bible.

    My impression is that Jim is reacting on the basis of an impression that MrRING was proposing the inclusion / consideration of texts above and beyond the set of any / all texts already accepted by at least one established sect / church.

    Or have I misinterpreted one or both positions? ... :dunno:
     
    MrRING, escargot and Naughty_Felid like this.
  12. jimv1

    jimv1 Analogue Boy

    Messages:
    8,301
    Likes Received:
    5,190
    Trophy Points:
    294
    The Paddington Hard Stare.
     
    escargot likes this.
  13. escargot

    escargot Beloved of Ra

    Messages:
    21,054
    Likes Received:
    10,482
    Trophy Points:
    284
    LOCATION:
    Farkham Hall
    Dunno. I enjoy reading about the 'alternative' contemporary rejected biblical texts though. It'd be nice to hear from an expert on the subject.
     
  14. MrRING

    MrRING Justified & Ancient

    Messages:
    4,863
    Likes Received:
    874
    Trophy Points:
    144
    The new direct quote function I haven't quite figured out, but I was meaning this thread as the Notorious En.G. suggested:
    ... I had never heard any idea that the Abraham/Isaac story might have had a different outcome in some portion of these old tales, so it made me wonder what other variations of just the normal Bible stories existed, as opposed to the more extravagant Apocrypha or banned bible books that got shoved out the window when "Da Bible" was structured in it's current form. Plus, since the location in this case was known as the Mountain of the Murderer, it would imply to me that locals considered the "Isaac Bites It" story was believed enough to make that the local name of the mountain, kind of like the Kroger grocery store in downtown Atlanta that was know as "Murder Kroger" due to crimes committed there.
     
  15. EnolaGaia

    EnolaGaia I knew the job was dangerous when I took it ...

    Messages:
    5,859
    Likes Received:
    5,397
    Trophy Points:
    294
    LOCATION:
    USA
    For the record ... After communicating privately with Jim, I've ascertained he was not responding on the basis of considering the Bible 'out of bounds' for such discussion or 'inviolate' by definition.


    Thanks for the clarification / confirmation ...
     
    ramonmercado likes this.
  16. escargot

    escargot Beloved of Ra

    Messages:
    21,054
    Likes Received:
    10,482
    Trophy Points:
    284
    LOCATION:
    Farkham Hall
    Personally I'm not bothered about the truth or otherwise of the religious/miraculous aspects of the Bible. What does interest me is the fact that 'new' ancient texts sometimes turn up which might back up or contradict the established biblical narrative.
     

Share This Page